Event Period
March 30, 2023 - April 9, 2023
Re-runs
Sep 20, 2024 - Sep 30, 2024
Nightmare Rarity, Retold is a siege event that was first held on March 30, 2023. It was held again on September 20, 2024. This event occurs years after the Nightmare Rarity and the Nightmare Strengths comic story arc.
Quests
Quest 1: Quest for Rest!
I know! Was it something I ate? Too many ghost stories? There has to be a way to get rid of them, but none of these books have a single cure!
Quest for Rest!
Required Level: 8
- Send Twilight Sparkle to research a cure for nightmares.
- Time:3 minutes
- Skip: 5

Rewards
- 2
, 30
and 10 Heart Necklace Shards
Oh, are we telling THIS story? This all happened a pretty long while ago... but it's a good one!
Quest 2: Slumber Soirée!
I know what'll help: a SLUMBER PARTY! If anything can chase away those heebie-jeebie dreams, it's a night of FUN! Everypony come over to my house later -- I'll get the fightin' pillows set up!
Slumber Soirée!
Required Level: 8
- Send Pinkie Pie to host a sleepover at her house.
- Time:5 minutes
- Skip: 5

Rewards
- 3
, 40
and 20 Heart Necklace Shards
Pinkie Pie's slumber parties are legendary... And they've only gotten better with time! There was a whole chocolate fountain at her last one...
Stages
Stage 1
For how to play Siege events see here.
100 health
1

per defeat
100 health
Requires gear levels 9/9
Dragon Shack Bowl (Décor)
Stage 2
800 health
2

per defeat
570 health
Requires gear levels 11/11
Nightmare Throne (Décor)
Stage 3
1500 health
3

per defeat
1200 health
Requires gear levels 18/18
Nightmare Path (Road)
Stage 4
4000 health
9

per defeat
4680 health
Requires gear levels 33/33
Stage 5
8000 health
24

per defeat
9880 health
Requires gear levels 49/49
Stage 6
15000 health
47

per defeat
21300 health
Requires gear levels 65/65
Stage 7
25000 health
77

per defeat
32100 health
Requires gear levels 81/81
| Nightmare Rarity, Retold Community Prizes
|
| 1–100th place
|
100th–500th place
|
500th–1000th place
|
| Feline Nyx
|
Rare Avatar (Dream Prince Spike)
|
20
|
| Nightmare Rarity, Retold Community Helpers
|
| Pony |
Multiplier |
Cooldown |
Expected Score
|
|
|
1x
|
2 hours
|
200
|
|
|
1x
|
2 hours
|
200
|
|
|
2x
|
3 hours
|
400
|
|
|
2x
|
3 hours
|
400
|
|
|
4x
|
5 hours
|
800
|
|
|
4x
|
5 hours
|
800
|
|
|
7x
|
8 hours
|
1400
|
Outfits
Collections
Story
Morning, Twilight! How'd ya sl--
UGH... Don't even ask, Sir Sleepsalot.
Aw, gee... ANOTHER nightmare?! That can't be good. You've had one every night this week!
I know! Was it something I ate? Too many ghost stories? There has to be a way to get rid of them, but none of these books have a single cure!
(Yaaaawn...) Not to be a pest, but would ya mind researchin' a little quieter, Twilight?
Yes... some of us haven't had our beauty rest. Whenever I close my eyes, I'm struck with such ghastly images!
What?! How can we ALL be having nightmares ALL week?
I know what'll help: a SLUMBER PARTY! If anything can chase away those heebie-jeebie dreams, it's a night of FUN! Everypony come over to my house later -- I'll get the fightin' pillows set up!